Go through the article and see if there are any major claims that are factually incorrect, or misleading. In case you find them, provide a “Confidence it’s wrong” score and a weight (how important it is to the overall thesis). Sort the results by importance to the thesis.
Use the example below to see how to write this and format it:
After that task, add an epistemic score and summary at the top of the artilcle, and [Epistemic score: 98/100 Very strong], with a short explanation of how to interpret the article’s output and main thesis.